
This is the kind of historical novel where I find it hard to read to the end, not because the writing is bad, but because I already know that things don't turn out well for the title character. I know Katherine Howard is executed by her middle aged husband Henry VIII, but
Suzannah Dunn was able to keep me reading through her artful story telling and believable characters, and in the process she skillfully portrays Katherine Howard as both a precocious child, and a sex-crazed woman. Dunn paints such a vivid picture of Katherine's days with her girlfriends and boyfriends before ascending the throne, that I just couldn't stop reading.
The story is told through the words of a childhood friend from the Duchess of Norfolk's home, another
teenaged girl who is a little less advanced than Katherine Howard herself in terms of sex and romance. Much of the charm of the book is the naive voice of this main character,
teenaged Cat
Tilney, as she approaches relationships under the tutelage of her more experienced friend, Katherine Howard. While Howard is naturally above it all, Cat deals with some of the same issues as any teen - trying to live up to the hopes and wishes of her family, falling in love, thinking about marriage, dealing with people she doesn't like, all in shadow of her magnetic friend. Whether or not Cat
Tilney actually existed historically I don't know at this point, but her portrayal here is so fascinating, that I can't wait to do more research on the topic.
I think it would be a good novel for teens to read, up to a point, as the execution of Katherine Howard at such a young age might clarify for teens why their parents warn them about life and its dangers. The only place the novel falls down for me is when Katherine Howard instructs her friend in medieval birth control methods, hoping she will follow her example and become sexually active. In contrast, the rest of the sex in the novel is handled with comparative subtlety.
All in all, a fascinating look at the early life of Katherine Howard, one of Henry
VIII's hapless queens, and how her whole life was a crazy train destined to end fatally for her and the men who loved her. More disturbing to see as a parent is how none of the adults in her life cared for her as anything but a mindless pawn formed to further their own ambitions in the cut-throat Tudor court. It might be instructive for older teens who don't yet realize how every choice they make, even while in the midst of those carefree teen years, can have serious implications for their adult lives.
Submitted by Gerti