Reading Level: Adult
Submitted by Gerti
This is the second novel I have read by mystery writer Simon Beckett, and it's a bit of a disappointment. It's only been a few weeks since I read his first one, "The Chemistry of Death," and his third, "Whispers of Death," which is perhaps even better than the first. "Written in Bone," however, does not come up to the level of the other two, despite the drama that lasts up until the final paragraphs.
In the novel in the series, the protagonist, Dr. David Hunter, came to a small British village called Manham in response to an advertisement for a general practitioner. The back story is that Hunter's wife and daughter were killed in an auto accident, and he left the city of London because he found it hard to deal with the death of his family constantly working on homicide cases for the police.
In the course of solving a series of murders in Manham, Hunter started dating a single school teacher Jenny. After she is kidnapped and then saved by him (of course!), the couple return to London, and Hunter goes back to his career as a forensic anthropologist because he realizes the dead need him to tell their tales. At the start of this second book in the series, Hunter has just finished one investigation, but is called in to help with what seems like a simple case in the Outer Hebrides on an island called Runa. The rest of Britain's forensic teams are busy working on a train crash with multiple victims, so Hunter feels obligated to go check out what looks at first to be a hobo burned by a fire set in an abandoned hut, which is discovered by Brody, a police detective who retired there. Hunter and Brody get on well, but are hindered in their investigation by a drunken Sergeant named Fraser, who feels Brody should have stayed retired.
The police team analyzes the strange burnt body, which looks to a young policeman to have spontaneously combusted, because the feet, ankles and a hand have remained unburnt. But Hunter soon realizes it's homicide, which means a crime team should be called in. The weather refuses to cooperate, however, and first communications with the outside world are lost, then the storm threatens to destroy the decrepit shelter in which the body is housed, forcing Hunter and his group to move the remains to the island's clinic. When the clinic catches on fire while Hunter is there trying to determine the victim's identity, he realizes that the killer is out to stop the team from solving this crime at all costs.
Beckett generally uses misdirection to throw the reader of the killer's trail, and in this book introduces several plausible red herrings before finally putting it all together at the end of this book. In the dramatic final pages, Hunter has been tracked back to his London apartment by the real murderer, who has somehow escaped a deadly fire on Runa. All this confustion and excitement is almost too much, and left my head spinning, trying to fit all the facts together. That confusion makes "Written in Bone" Beckett's weakest book, but it is worth reading for fans.