Since this is the second Beth Pattillo novel that riffs on a Jane Austen theme I've read, I've become familiar with Pattillo's plots, which generally include a set of sisters in conflict. This is the theme behind "Mr. Darcy Broke My Heart", although men do play a part in the story, as the title might indicate. In this novel, Claire Prescott, laid off administrative assistant, is taking her college-educated sister Missy's place at a Jane Austen convention in England because of Missy's pregnancy. Back in the states, Claire leaves behind a boyfriend named Neil who is so wrapped up in sports that she doesn't even think he will notice her departure. While at Oxford, Claire meets a Darcy-like fellow named James who is handsome, arrogant, rich and well-connected. What she doesn't realize till the end is that he is also a scam artist.
It's a little more obvious to the reader what is going on, as Claire's charms are obviously not up to standard that Manhattan publisher James is used to encountering. But the surprise comes when Neil makes his way to England because he has turned off the TV and realized he does loy~ Claire.and.can't live without her. After a comedy of errors in which Neil catches Claire with James, Claire realizes that she too loves Neil and not her "Mr. Darcy" stand-in, and the original couple gets back together for their return flight to the states, plus one engagement ring.
The most interesting part of the book, however, is not this off-again, on-again romance between Neil and Claire, or even the conflict between hard-working Claire and her more intellectual sister. The real fun comes in when Claire helps a seemingly dotty old British woman back to her cottage, and discovers that this woman has an original copy of Jane Austen's "First Impressions" scattered around the house (and in the garden shed.) Any Austen fan knows that "First Impressions" was the original title of Austen's "Pride and Prejudice," from which the character Mr. Darcy emerges. But as the old woman lets Claire read through some of the pages, it becomes clear that in this faux original version (invented by Pattillo for the book), Elizabeth Bennet does not end up with Mr. Darcy at all, an ending which mirrors the real life scenario of Claire, Neil and James.
The original manuscript takes up a large part of the novel, and is in fact the most
interesting part, even though Pattillo's style of "writing Austen" does not have the
wit and charm of Austen. Still, it is fun to see Elizabeth Bennet end up withanother character than Darcy, and the various twists and turns Pattillo's version
of "Pride and Prejudice" takes make it a worthwhile read. I can't wait to read
Pattillo's third novel, "Jane Austen Ruined My Life."
Submitted by Gerti