by Cathleen Schine
Reviewed by Gerti
“The
Three Weissmanns of Westport” is Cathleen Schine’s take on
Jane Austen’s classic novel, “Sense and Sensibility.” If you
are unfamiliar with the hundred-year-old original, it was about two
sisters, one practical and the other emotional, who have to survive
their father’s death and their subsequent poverty. Being single
women, they also look for and find romance, although the road to that
isn’t smooth either. Likewise, Schine has two female protagonists
in this story, Annie (the practical sister) and Miranda (the
impulsive one). Both girls move to a cottage in Westport, CT, from
New York City not because of their father’s death, but because he
has found a mistress and decided to divorce their mother, Betty. She
receives a kind offer from her wealthy Cousin Lou to move into an
unrented beach property of his after Joseph Weissman freezes the
couple’s assets and she can no longer afford their Central Park
West apartment.
Seventy-eight-year-old
Joe met his young mistress, Felicity, at work, and while he feels he
is being generous to his wife, it is obvious to his step-daughters
that he is not. Annie knows all about bad men, since she has been
divorced before, but she also has two grown sons whom she loves, and
a great job at a bookstore in the city. In fact it is Felicity who
introduces her to her famous author brother, Frederick Barrow. He
does a wonderful reading of his literary work’s there at the
bookstore, and Annie and Frederick have a secret tryst. When
Frederick’s snobby grown children try to keep Annie away from their
father, little do they suspect an even worse fate is in store for
him, thanks to a minx of a house sitter named Amber. Fans of “Sense
and Sensibility” will recognize that Amber is the reincarnated Lucy
Steele, who in the Austen book “steals” an eligible man away from
the sensible sister while pretending to be her friend.
Miranda’s
life is also falling apart in parallel with that of her mother. She
has never been able to settle down and marry (since she likes falling
in love so much) but has built a successful career as a literary
agent with her own agency. Now however, it seems some memoirs she has
published were mere fabrications, and her reputation and her business
falter, bankrupting her. She runs away to live with her mother in
Westport, only to fall in love with a handsome local actor named Kit
Maybank. He saved her during an ill-fated kayak trip during a
thunderstorm. Unfortunately, he has a young son named Henry and seems
to use Miranda more as a babysitter than a love interest. He leaves
as soon as a good part becomes available in LA, and Miranda realizes
she loved being a mother to Henry more than she loved Kit. So when
the child’s mother Leanne comes on the scene, Miranda naturally
falls in love with her, too.
Schine’s
story is charming and modern. Austen fans will recognize who each
character is meant to be, but I don’t know whether the ending will
satisfy them, or me! I did think Schine’s writing was very good.
She used very clever phrases and seems, like Austen, to understand
human emotion and evil motivations very well.
1 comment:
Yes, I know. "Sense and Sensibility" has 3 sisters in it - Elinor, Marianne and Margaret. But just as some movie versions leave out the youngest girl since she doesn't play a major role, I left her out of this in order to make the point that the books are SIMILAR. I should have written "S & S" is primarily about the 2 Dashwood sisters, which would have been more accurate. Sorry if my verbal error caused any confusion.
Post a Comment